BoardGamesWarehouse.co.uk

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective box art

★★★★★ 4.6 (1,875) on Amazon · by Asmodee

1–8 playersages 14+

New£38.83RRP £47.99

Fair price. About its usual price. The 12-month low was £32.70.

£38.83 at Amazon

Prices checked 17 Nov 2026, 04:30. They change often, and Amazon's price at checkout is the one that counts.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective price history

90-day average (new)
£39.10
12-month low
£32.70
12-month high
£44.94
Cheapest used now
£60.84
Usually cheapest in
February
£26£36£47£57£67Nov 2025May 2026Nov 2026
NewAmazonUsed

Daily prices on Amazon.co.uk over the last 12 months. How we track prices.

Our review of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective

7/10 value for money

This is a cooperative deduction game for one to eight players, built around ten Sherlock Holmes cases set in Victorian London. You examine evidence, read newspapers for clues and follow leads around the city, working either solo or as a group of Baker Street Irregulars. It leans towards reading, discussion and reasoning rather than dice and turn order, and the 14+ age guidance plus a 60 to 120 minute session suit adults and older teens who enjoy a puzzle.

A 4.6 out of 5 from over 2,400 ratings is a strong signal by Amazon standards, with enough volume behind it to take seriously. Do note that the cases are the content, so this is a game people tend to work through over several evenings rather than replay endlessly.

At £39.99 you're paying a little under the 90-day average and a fair way below RRP, so it's a reasonable rather than remarkable moment to buy. It has been noticeably cheaper within the past year, so patient shoppers may want to wait for another dip. No Warehouse copies are listed at the moment.

What we like

  • Strong 4.6/5 rating from a large number of reviews
  • Ten cases with solo or group play
  • Flexible player count, one to eight
  • Currently below RRP and the recent average

Watch out for

  • Has been considerably cheaper in the last year
  • Case-based content limits long-term replay value
  • 14+ age guide and long sessions; not for families

Best for: Adults and older teens who love reading, logic and mysteries

Our review is written from the publisher's details, Amazon customer ratings and our price tracking. We don't take payment from publishers.

What Amazon customers think

★★★★★ 4.6 (1,875)

1,875 Amazon customers have rated Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, averaging 4.6 out of 5. It is currently ranked #20,875 in Toys & Games on Amazon.co.uk.

100+ bought on Amazon in the past month.

Read the customer reviews on Amazon

About Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective

  • Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective has returned with both brand new and revised cases for you and your fellow investigators to solve.
  • A game of deduction, logic and cunning mysteries; examine the evidence, scour the newspaper for clues and travel around London wherever your instinct leads you.
  • Become the hero of 10 original Sherlock Holmes adventures and work either alone or with friends to find the truth.
  • Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is a cooperative game where players are members of the Baker Street Irregulars. Will you solve the mysterious cases by walking the streets in search of clues?
  • Solve 10 mysteries in Victorian London! The Mummy's Curse, The Munitions Magnate, The Pilfered Paintings, The Thames Murders. Strange cases of the most famous detective ever: Sherlock Holmes!

From the publisher's product listing.

Game details

Players1–8
Age14+
PublisherAsmodee
ASIN2370990074

See every Asmodee game and today's cheapest →

Get an alert for this game

We'll email you when it drops to your price or turns up Like New in Amazon Warehouse.

Tell me about

No spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy notice.

More games worth a look