BoardGamesWarehouse.co.uk

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective box art

★★★★★ 4.5 (489) on Amazon · by Asmodee

1–8 playersages 14+90 min

New£36.99RRP £47.99

Fair price. About its usual price. The 12-month low was £29.12.

£36.99 at Amazon

Prices checked 17 Nov 2026, 04:30. They change often, and Amazon's price at checkout is the one that counts.

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective price history

90-day average (new)
£39.05
12-month low
£29.12
12-month high
£47.99
Cheapest used now
£56.41
Usually cheapest in
July
£26£35£44£53£62Nov 2025May 2026Nov 2026
NewAmazonUsed

Daily prices on Amazon.co.uk over the last 12 months. How we track prices.

Our review of Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

7/10 value for money

This is a co-operative deduction game in the Consulting Detective range: you and up to seven others play Wiggins' Baker Street Irregulars, questioning suspects, reading newspapers and chasing clues through London before comparing your conclusions with Holmes's. There are ten cases here, written by British Sherlock Holmes specialist Dave Neale, plus a system that tracks your progress through each investigation. It leans towards reading, discussion and careful note-taking rather than tactical play, so it suits puzzle-minded groups, couples and solo players happy with a 90-minute sitting. The 14+ age guide feels meaningful given the text-heavy nature.

The Amazon rating is strong and, unusually, backed by a large number of ratings, so 4.6 out of 5 is decent evidence that the cases land well for most buyers.

On price, today's figure sits just under Amazon's own price and slightly below the 90-day average, and comfortably below RRP. It has been noticeably cheaper within the last year, though, so if you're not in a hurry it may be worth watching. No Warehouse copies are listed at the moment.

What we like

  • Strong 4.6/5 rating from a large number of reviewers
  • Ten new cases written by a Sherlock Holmes specialist
  • Co-operative and plays anywhere from one to eight
  • Priced below RRP and the 90-day average

Watch out for

  • Has dropped considerably lower in the past year
  • 14+ age guide; text-heavy and reading-led
  • 90 minutes per case suits patient groups only
  • No Amazon Warehouse copies available right now

Best for: Puzzle-loving groups and solo players who enjoy story-driven deduction

Our review is written from the publisher's details, Amazon customer ratings and our price tracking. We don't take payment from publishers.

What Amazon customers think

★★★★★ 4.5 (489)

489 Amazon customers have rated Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective, averaging 4.5 out of 5.

Sells steadily on Amazon (32 sales spikes in 90 days).

Read the customer reviews on Amazon

About Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

  • Sherlock Holmes calls on you to solve ten new cases. Will you rise to the challenge
  • In Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective, you and your fellow players are Wiggins†Baker Street Irregulars, the London urchins who assist the mastermind detective in his investigations
  • With this box, the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective range expands with ten new cases. Written by Dave Neale, a British Sherlock Holmes specialist, these cases will challenge all players
  • This box introduces players to a clever system that calculates their progress throughout each investigation and places the Baker Street Irregulars at the heart of all cases
  • For 1 to 8 players
  • 90 minutes play time
  • Ages 14 and up

Product Description

Product Description Sherlock Holmes is a cooperative game. You and your fellow players are Wiggins’ Baker Street Irregulars, the London urchins who assist the mastermind detective in his investigations. Interrogate suspects, carefully read the newspapers, and go in search of clues throughout the London streets. When you believe you have solved the case, compare your findings to those of Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock Holmes calls on you to solve ten new cases. Will you rise to the challenge? With this box, the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective range expands with ten new cases. Written by Dave Neale, a British Sherlock Holmes specialist, these cases will challenge all players. In addition, this box introduces players to a clever system that calculates their progress throughout each investigation and places the Baker Street Irregulars at the heart of all cases. Safety Warning Not suitable for children under the age of 3 years

Safety Warning

Not suitable for children under the age of 3 years

From the publisher's product listing.

Game details

Players1–8
Age14+
Play time90 minutes
PublisherAsmodee
ASIN2370990112

See every Asmodee game and today's cheapest →

Get an alert for this game

We'll email you when it drops to your price or turns up Like New in Amazon Warehouse.

Tell me about

No spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy notice.

More games worth a look