BoardGamesWarehouse.co.uk

Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society

Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society box art

★★★★☆ 4.2 (31) on Amazon · by Professor PUZZLE

1+ playersages 12+

New£19.99

Maybe wait. Dearer than usual right now. It has averaged £17.66 over 90 days, so it may be worth setting an alert.

£19.99 at Amazon

Prices checked 14 Nov 2026, 04:30. They change often, and Amazon's price at checkout is the one that counts.

Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society price history

90-day average (new)
£17.66
12-month low
£11.99
12-month high
£19.99
Usually cheapest in
April
£10£13£16£18£21Nov 2025May 2026Nov 2026
NewAmazon

Daily prices on Amazon.co.uk over the last 12 months. How we track prices.

Our review of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society

3/10 value for money

This is a single-player brain-teaser rather than a board game: a sliding block puzzle, dressed in a Sherlock Holmes story about infiltrating a secret society, where you shift pieces around a map block to free a hidden membership token. It's aimed at 12 and over, and it's a solo item, so treat it as a gift or a quiet desk challenge rather than something for games night. The publisher doesn't state how long it takes, and with one puzzle to solve, replay value is likely limited once you've cracked it.

The Amazon score of 4.2 out of 5 is decent, but it rests on only 30 ratings, which is thin evidence either way. The sales rank is low, so it's a niche item.

On price, this is the weak point. The current asking price matches the twelve-month high and sits above the ninety-day average, while the same puzzle has been available for little more than half that within the past year. There are no Warehouse offers at the moment. If you want it, it's worth waiting for a drop.

What we like

  • Neat solo brain-teaser with a Sherlock Holmes theme
  • Self-contained puzzle, no setup or rules to learn
  • Decent 4.2 rating from buyers so far
  • Makes an easy gift for puzzle fans

Watch out for

  • Price is at its twelve-month high
  • One player only, so no group play
  • Just 30 ratings: weak evidence of quality
  • Single puzzle, likely limited replay value

Best for: Solo puzzle fans who can wait for a price drop

Our review is written from the publisher's details, Amazon customer ratings and our price tracking. We don't take payment from publishers.

What Amazon customers think

★★★★☆ 4.2 (31)

31 Amazon customers have rated Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society, averaging 4.2 out of 5. It is currently ranked #203,096 in Toys & Games on Amazon.co.uk.

Sells steadily on Amazon (6 sales spikes in 90 days).

Read the customer reviews on Amazon

About Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Secret Society

  • The Society of Shadows is a clandestine brotherhood seeking to exploit their ancestor's connections and establish themselves as London's criminal overlords. To infiltrate the society and gain evidence to put them behind bars, Holmes must retrieve a special membership token hidden inside an intricate sliding map block puzzle. Can you move the token into the correct position to release it?

From the publisher's product listing.

Game details

Players1+
Age12+
PublisherProfessor PUZZLE
ASINB088B3MPS7

Get an alert for this game

We'll email you when it drops to your price or turns up Like New in Amazon Warehouse.

Tell me about

No spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy notice.

More games worth a look