BoardGamesWarehouse.co.uk

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective:

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: box art

★★★★☆ 4.3 (487) on Amazon · by Asmodee

1–8 playersages 14+90 min

New£33.95RRP £42.99

Maybe wait. Dearer than usual right now. It has averaged £30.66 over 90 days, so it may be worth setting an alert.

£33.95 at Amazon

Prices checked 13 Nov 2026, 04:32. They change often, and Amazon's price at checkout is the one that counts.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: price history

90-day average (new)
£30.66
12-month low
£18.54
12-month high
£34.93
Usually cheapest in
April
£16£24£33£41£49Nov 2025May 2026Nov 2026
NewAmazon

Daily prices on Amazon.co.uk over the last 12 months. How we track prices.

Our review of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective:

6/10 value for money

This is a mystery-solving game for one to eight players, built around ten cases drawn from two previously out-of-print expansions, now revised and updated. You read, follow leads and try to crack each case in fewer steps than Holmes himself. It leans heavily on reading and discussion rather than dice or boards, so it suits patient groups, couples and solo players who enjoy puzzling things out. The 14+ age guide feels honest given the text-heavy nature, and sessions run long at 60 to 120 minutes.

An Amazon rating of 4.3 from 484 ratings is a solid, reasonably well-evidenced score, though it's worth noting cases are one-and-done: once solved, replay value is limited.

On price, today's figure sits a shade above the 90-day average and well above the twelve-month low, so it isn't a standout deal, even if it's a good chunk under RRP. If you're not in a hurry, waiting for a drop closer to that low would be the smarter buy. No Warehouse copies are listed at the moment.

What we like

  • Ten cases from two hard-to-find, updated expansions
  • Works solo or with up to eight
  • Comfortably under RRP at today's price
  • Strong 4.3 rating from a decent sample

Watch out for

  • Priced above the 90-day average and yearly low
  • Cases are largely single-use once solved
  • Long, text-heavy sessions; 14+ for good reason

Best for: Patient puzzle-lovers and solo players who enjoy reading-led mysteries

Our review is written from the publisher's details, Amazon customer ratings and our price tracking. We don't take payment from publishers.

What Amazon customers think

★★★★☆ 4.3 (487)

487 Amazon customers have rated Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective:, averaging 4.3 out of 5. It is currently ranked #63,656 in Toys & Games on Amazon.co.uk.

Sells steadily on Amazon (30 sales spikes in 90 days).

Read the customer reviews on Amazon

About Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective:

  • Welcome to the Carlton House, enjoy the luxury and solve the murders
  • Carlton House and Queen's Park introduces ten exciting cases
  • Includes two classic, long out of print expansions which are now revised and updated
  • Try to surpass the most famous detective
  • For 1 to 8 players | 90 minutes play time | Ages 14 and up

From the publisher's product listing.

Game details

Players1–8
Age14+
Play time90 minutes
PublisherAsmodee
ASIN2370990090

See every Asmodee game and today's cheapest →

Get an alert for this game

We'll email you when it drops to your price or turns up Like New in Amazon Warehouse.

Tell me about

No spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy notice.

More games worth a look